What does a heart-led, evidence-based approach mean?

Only when head and heart work in harmony, can we obtain our true human potential” Jane Goodall

A heart-led, evidence-based approach is often referred to as the art and science of midwifery. A healthy combination of clinical skills, evidence, experience, instinct, curiosity, relationality and compassion.

A detailed illustration of a tree with branches and roots, depicted in white with blue accents, set against a black background.

My approach to providing evidence-based care, is about being realistic that unfortunately there is limited high-quality research into women’s health. Therefore, I am interested in examining the evidence that recommendations and guidelines are based upon. I believe one of the most important aspects in how evidence based care should be provided is by the clinician being aware of any potential biases, fears and agendas they may have.

A heart-led approach to midwifery, for me, means prioritising compassion, empathy and connection, and being attentive to and valuing instinctive knowledge.

What does safety mean to you?

I am interested in what safety means to you, physical, emotional and psychological safety. I recognise how ‘risk’ and ‘safety’ are often viewed through a limited and biased lens, one which often fails to acknowledge that for every individual, what they perceive as a risk and what they need to feel safe is different. Part of figuring out what safety means to you involves examining your belief systems around birth and what you’ve heard about birth, as this can have an impact on the choices you make for you and your baby. What I have come to know is that when a woman feels seen and heard, understood and held without fear and judgement, this creates safety.

We are incredibly lucky in the UK to have access to free, high quality medical resources and services, with highly skilled and dedicated maternity clinicians. As a midwife and mother I am deeply grateful for these services. I know that medical interventions can be the most loving, safest and kindest course of action when they come from a place of choice, understanding and consent. Unfortunately, there are also high levels of fear and defensive practice within current maternity services, which in part comes from trying to implement a narrow view of ‘safety’. This can and often causes iatrogenic harm (harm caused by unnecessary interventions). The problems within our NHS maternity services are multifaceted and acute. What I dream of is a maternity service which prioritise trauma informed care, that nurtures and cares for its staff so they can nurture and care for families. A service which strives for equity and inclusivity by valuing the needs of the most vulnerable and minoritised people in our communities, and by doing so will create models of care which are better for all.

From 2005 I began working with families as a voluntary breastfeeding counsellor with La Leche.         

In 2014 I qualified as a midwife and in 2019, alongside working as a midwife, I became a Professional Midwifery Advocate (PMA) providing supervision and support to midwives.

Most of my career in the NHS has been as a community midwife, working within an integrated system providing care across the whole perinatal journey.  

In 2021, due to my interest in improving maternity services and supporting midwives, I progressed into a specialist role as lead Retention Midwife and lead PMA at Torbay and South Devon NHS Trust.

In 2023 I won a SW Maternity & Neonatal Innovation Award for my work in retention of midwives .  

In 2024 I was invited by the RCM to speak to the APPG in parliament on retention of midwives. My retention work has been discussed in the following research Novel solutions to the midwifery retention crisis in England: an organisational case study of midwives' intentions to leave the profession and the role of retention midwives - PubMed

From 2022 - 25 I developed and led a Birth Afterthoughts clinic at Torbay Hospital, to support families who have experienced birth trauma.

In 2023 I produced ’Freebirthing a short documentary’, which is now being used within NHS maternity services and universities to support discussion around perceptions of risk, personalisation and choice. I developed and teach a workshop with student midwives entitled ‘Providing choice within a culture of fear’, as a way of addressing the challenges to providing personalised care in maternity services. 

I won a daisy award in 2024 https://www.daisyfoundation.org/daisy-award/honorees/josephine-ash

As part of my determination to reduce birth trauma and obstetric violence I am part of the growing research team of The Birth Experience Study UK - BESt The Birth Experience Study - UK (BESt -UK) - King's College London (kcl.ac.uk)

I now work as an independent midwife in Devon, and as an independent midwife consultant with The White ribbon alliance  https://freefromharm.co.uk